Why 40% Of EV Car Insurance Claims Are Flagged For Battery Negligence And How To Avoid It

Electric cars are no longer rare on Indian roads. You see them in apartment basements, office parking lots and traffic jams just like any other car. The shift feels natural now. Lower running costs, fewer moving parts and the promise of cleaner travel all make sense. But insurance claims tell a different story. A large share of EV claims, close to 40%, end up flagged for battery negligence. And most owners are caught off guard when that happens.

This is not because EV owners are careless. It is because battery rules are new, unclear and often buried deep inside policy wording. Many people learn the hard way, after a claim gets delayed or rejected. Let’s break this down in plain terms. Why is this happening so often? And what can you do to stay clear of it?
 

The Battery is not Just Another Car Part

In a petrol or diesel car, engine damage is serious but predictable. In an electric car, the battery is everything. It decides range, performance, resale value and repair cost. The battery alone can cost anywhere between 40 to 60% of the car’s price. That changes how insurers look at risk. A cracked bumper is one thing. A damaged battery is a very different story.

Most EV owners assume that if their car is insured, the battery is automatically covered in every situation. That assumption causes trouble as EV car insurance works on conditions. And EV batteries come with more conditions than most people expect.
 

Where Claims Start Going Wrong

Battery negligence does not mean deliberate damage. In most cases, it means the insurer believes the damage happened due to avoidable actions or improper use. Here are the most common reasons claims get flagged:

• Water Damage During Floods
  This is one of the biggest triggers. EVs are designed to handle rain and shallow water. But driving through deep water, parking in flooded basements, or charging the car after water exposure can cause serious battery damage.
  If the insurer finds signs that the car was used in unsafe water levels, the claim can be questioned. Many policies clearly state that damage due to reckless water exposure may not be paid. And no, the car turning on afterward does not help your case. Battery damage can show up days later.
   
• Charging with Non-Approved Equipment
  Using a local extension cord or an uncertified charger feels harmless. But insurers and manufacturers do not see it that way. If a battery issue traces back to overheating, short circuits, or voltage mismatch, the charging setup is examined closely. Non-approved chargers often lead to claim disputes.
  This catches many owners off guard, especially those charging at home or in shared parking spaces.
   
• Ignoring Basic Charging Discipline
  Overcharging, deep discharging too often, or using fast charging as a daily habit can slowly damage battery health. When a claim is raised, insurers may ask for service data and charging history. If the battery shows stress patterns linked to poor charging habits, the word negligence enters the picture.
   
• Delayed Reporting after an Incident
  Battery damage is not always visible. After a minor accident or water exposure, many owners keep driving and report issues weeks later. Insurers expect immediate reporting. Delays make it harder to link damage to a specific event. That gap often weakens the claim.
   

Why Does EV Insurance Still Feel Confusing?

EV insurance is evolving. Policies look familiar on the surface, but the details are different. Some batteries are insured as part of the car. Others are treated as separate components, especially when leased or covered under manufacturer warranties.

Then there are add-ons. Battery protection covers, zero depreciation and return-to-invoice options all change how claims work. Many buyers skip these details at purchase. The focus stays on premium price, not coverage depth. That is understandable. But it also explains why so many claims run into trouble.
 

How to Protect Yourself Before Anything Goes Wrong?

The good news is that battery negligence flags are largely avoidable. You do not need expert knowledge or technical obsession. You just need clarity and a few steady habits.

• Choose the Right Coverage from Day One
  Not all electric car insurance policies are built the same. Some offer basic battery cover. Others need add-ons for full protection. A battery protection add-on can cover damage from water ingress, short circuits and power surges, depending on the insurer. Without it, many situations fall into grey areas.
  This is where platforms like SMC Insurance help. Since we work with multiple leading insurers, we can compare EV-specific coverage properly, not just premiums.
   
• Read the Battery Clauses
  Policy documents are helpful but incomplete. The battery section matters more than most people think. Look for exclusions related to water levels, charging methods and usage guidelines. If something sounds vague, ask before buying.
  It is much easier to fix gaps before a claim than after.
   
• Stick to Approved Charging Practices
  Use manufacturer-recommended chargers. Install proper home charging units if possible. Avoid makeshift setups, even if they seem convenient. Public charging stations are fine, but avoid damaged connectors or unstable power sources. These details may feel small, but they matter during claim reviews.
   
• Be Careful During Monsoons
  Indian roads flood quickly. EVs can handle some water, but they are not boats. Avoid flooded roads when possible. Do not charge the vehicle immediately after water exposure. If the car has been through deep water, inform the service center and insurer early.
  Early reporting protects you more than silence ever will.
   
• Keep Service Records Clean
  Regular servicing and software updates help show responsible ownership. If a claim arises, clean records support your case. Missed services and ignored alerts weaken it.

Wrapping Up,

Electric cars are here to stay. This means that battery tech will improve and insurance will adapt. But right now, owners are caught in the middle of change. That 40% claim flag rate cannot be seen as a warning against EVs, but as a signal to approach EV insurance with more care.

Most claim issues do not come from bad intent. They come from missing information. Hence, get the right cover, follow basic usage discipline and ask questions early. Do that and battery negligence becomes something you read about, not something you deal with firsthand.

FAQs